Hello and welcome to this podcast from Teacher magazine, the resource for K-12 educators published by ACER, the Australian Council for Educational Research. I'm the editor of Teacher, Jo Earp, and I'll be your host today.
It's Episode 115 of The Research Files and we're talking about maths anxiety today – what it looks like for students and teachers, what we know from the research about the impact and the strategies and supports that can make a difference. I always find this a really fascinating topic, actually. I've got a great expert in the studio with me who's going to be bringing us up to speed, my ACER colleague Dr Sarah Buckley. As usual, I'll put links to the resources, the research and any papers that we mention in our chat in the transcript of this episode over at teachermagazine.com. Okay, let's dive in.
Jo Earp: Dr Sarah Buckley, thanks for joining Teacher for this episode of The Research Files. I'm really keen to get started on this one. As I was saying there, I find this a really interesting area, and I know it's a popular one with our listeners too. So, there's lots and lots to talk about. But, before we do that, it'd be great to hear about your research work and interest in this area.
Sarah Buckley: Well, first, thanks for having me, Jo. I think I've been working on, I was trying to remember before coming in for this recording, I think I've been working on maths anxiety for over 20 years, which is a bit ridiculous! So, that was even before my time at ACER. And, at ACER we've been doing a lot of research on maths anxiety for over 10 years; really trying to understand how it impacts learning, how it presents, how we can recognise it and identify it, and how we can address it.
JE: And your role at ACER, then, what's your actual title then at ACER? And you're involved in other research aren't you as well as maths anxiety?
SB: Yes, I'm a Senior Research Fellow in the Tertiary and Professional Education Research team and I work in the maths anxiety space in the sort of STEM equity space. So, looking at trying to get, and make sure, that everyone feels that STEM learning and opportunities are accessible for them and interesting for them. And I also do a lot of work in the Australia Awards space, which is Australia's international scholarship program for people from low- and middle-income countries. So, I get to do lots of different things, which is really fun.
JE: So, it seems to me then that there's been an increase in the research exploring maths anxiety in the school years, and also a deeper understanding of what's happening for teachers and students, in the last few years in particular. Why is that?
SB: I think people are looking at it more for 2 big reasons. One, because of its impact on learning and mathematics-related choices; so, choices about whether to continue on with maths. Because I think the main long-term consequence of maths anxiety is avoidance. So, we’re in this kind of landscape where people are trying to push as many people as possible into that sort of STEM area because we know that it's a growing field and it's where we do a lot of innovation. If people are avoiding maths, it means that they're really closing the door on some of those opportunities, because maths is really integral to STEM. So, I think when we're trying to encourage people to do that, maths anxiety is a real barrier to that. So, I think that's why people are focusing on it. But also, just in the moment, it can really impact on students’ learning. It's … anxiety if you're experiencing maths anxiety at high levels it's not very pleasant, you know, so what can we do about it and help make maths learning a bit more comfortable and maybe even fun?
JE: So, when we talk about maths anxiety then, what does that actually mean? The other thing I want to point out is, again, we're talking about not just the students in your class – which I guess would sort of spring to mind first of all – but teacher maths anxiety too. So, what do we mean by maths anxiety?
SB: So, maths anxiety is the worry, the fear, the tension that you feel when you are anticipating doing maths or doing maths. It's not test or performance anxiety, which people sometimes get confused, or confuse maths anxiety with. So, test or performance anxiety is the anxiety you feel when you have to do a test or perform. That's very different. Maths anxiety is when you are really worried about doing something maths related. So doing a maths test is going to make you feel often the most anxious if you are a maths anxious person. But you also might get anxious when you're like walking into your maths classroom or opening up your maths textbook to do some homework.
For a teacher that's maths anxious, it means that as you are preparing lessons that are maths related, you might start to feel some of that worry. You might also do things like avoid teaching maths where you can because it's something that really worries you. So, you know, if you've got your – this is one of the things that we see in the research (Park, et al., 2024; Bursal & Paznokas, 2006) is that, for instance, in primary teachers where we do see higher proportions of maths anxiety sometimes, if you have a lesson or something that needs to be put into the day, like something that needs to be slotted in, then often maths anxious teachers will choose to replace maths rather than something else because it's something that they would prefer to avoid. Again, coming back to that thing of avoidance is often the biggest consequence, the long-term consequence of maths anxiety.
JE: So, let's pick up on some of those other consequences then and some of the impacts. So, we were talking avoidance. Obviously, you’ve said it's just not nice, is it? Why is this such an important area to tackle then?
SB: So, I think from that point, for students we really do want students to not limit their opportunities for pursuing maths because they are anxious about it. So, we need to give them strategies to be able to regulate that anxiety. We also don't want it to impact on their ability to demonstrate their potential. Because often one of the key things that maths anxiety does is it actually, it interrupts working memory. So, it means that we often hear students who say, ‘I studied and then I got into the test and I froze’. And that's often because working memory is being interrupted by anxiety, that feeling in the moment. And so, we really want students to be able to demonstrate their potential. So, let's give them some strategies to regulate that anxiety.
For teachers, what we often see is that teachers that are maths anxious – because they're avoiding it and also because often they feel a bit of shame associated with feeling the anxiety – they won't seek help if they do need it in order to sort of build confidence. They might not seek help from colleagues. And one of the things that I like to say to teachers is that one of the key theories that we use in our research at ACER is, it's called the Control-Value Theory of achievement emotions (Pekrun, 2024). And it helps us understand the experience of anxiety. And it says that anxiety is the product of valuing something, but feeling like you have no control over it.
Because, in order to be anxious about something, you have to value it. If you don't value it, then you wouldn't be anxious. You would just be like, ‘whatever, I don't care’. So that's a really important thing to focus on for teachers. Teachers that are anxious about maths, value maths. They want to do a good job. They want to do good by their students. They want to make sure that their students learn, but they feel like they don't have any control over their maths teaching. And so, I think that's an important message to give to teachers that are maths anxious to remove any shame. Because what we want to do is we want to make sure that if you are a maths anxious teacher, let's give you strategies to regulate your own anxiety so then you can seek help – because there's nothing wrong with needing help. And often we might find that those teachers probably have no issue with seeking help in some of the other subjects they teach, but for some reason there's a lot of stigma associated with needing help in maths.
JE: Yeah. So, what you're talking about is good for reducing that stigma and like you say, reducing that sort of feeling of shame. I want to, so we're talking about both teachers and students, I want to focus on students now for a while. Is there a difference in relation to age then in terms of what students are feeling? And at that younger end, how old are we talking about at the point of it starting to appear?
SB: So, in the research, it's been documented as presenting as early as 6-years-old in children (Tomasetto et al., 2021). I think when you look at the body of research on maths motivation and engagement and anxiety, where it seems to really start to impact on students' learning tends to be upper primary and early secondary (Ma, 1999; Barrosco et al., 2021). I don't think it's a coincidence that that's when fractions and algebra start to come into the curriculum – and they're things that are often associated with a bit more anxiety. So, we do see that trend there of where it really does start to peak, but yeah as young as 6.
JE: Okay, so you've touched on maybe some of the potential causes there at an early age and that upper primary level in terms of topics like fractions coming in and algebra. I'm guessing that student voice is crucial here in terms of understanding the causes. What is it that they're telling us?
SB: I think students often describe, when they're anxious, they often sort of just say, ‘I'm just bad at it. I just can't do it’. And I think that brings us back to that theory that I mentioned before, that Control-Value Theory and that idea that anxiety is experienced when you value something but don't have control over it. And so that lack of control is that root cause of an anxious experience. So, feeling like you do not have control over your maths capability, potential and things like that. And that is essentially a fixed mindset in maths. So, thinking, ‘It doesn't matter how much I practice or study, I'm just not going to get better’. And that can come from lots of different places.
It can come in the home. So, for instance, if you have parents that are saying, ‘I was never very good at maths, so you're not likely to be’, you're thinking that it's a genetic thing. It can come from experiences in the classroom. Some students will talk about having an experience with a teacher who has told them, ‘Oh you're just not a maths person’. It can even come from culture … I'd like to say that gender stereotypes about maths are gone and we don't have to contend with them anymore, but they still are out there. That idea that students that identify as girls or female, that they are not as good at maths. And so that might influence your mindset around maths if you identify as a girl and you think therefore, ‘… my potential is just not as good, just naturally’. So, there are a lot of different places that it can come from. And then if you feel like you just don't have that control to get better and it's important, because your family's telling you it's important to do well in maths or because it's important for what you want to do when you get older, then you're going to feel anxious.
JE: And as you were saying, that idea that you value it. So maybe again, in the home, it's a really valued skill or yourself, you're thinking, ‘Oh, I need to get this. I need to get this for the career that I want’. So, certainly, going up into secondary or whatever. So that makes sense. But for teachers then, and for parents and families, what about the strategies that we can use to help students? Again, I'm interested, are there different things that are more impactful for different ages?
SB: So, basically, for parents what we will really want to do is focus on stopping the development of a fixed mindset in maths. So, parents can reflect on how they're talking about maths at home. Are they talking about it with positive language? Are they talking about maths in the same way they talk about reading, sport, science, music? Just trying to really reflect on that and make sure that they are encouraging this idea that everyone can get better in maths. We're not trying to get them to say, to encourage their children to be mathematicians. All we're trying to do is just say everyone can get better and that making mistakes in maths is okay.
I think there is a stigma around making mistakes in maths. Often one of the things that I'll say to some students is, ‘If you are playing AFL and you drop the ball or you don't make the kick, Do you just give up and think that you cannot do it anymore? No, you try, you practice, maths is the same’. So, let's think about doing the same thing, taking the same approach in all these different subjects. I think the other thing that parents can do as kids get older is just gently make them aware of all of the different applications of maths in life, and in all the different jobs that are out there, that's really important.
When it comes to teachers, I think there's different things that they can do depending on the age of the kids. So, we talk about different things, but the main thing in our work at ACER is we differentiate between the symptoms of maths anxiety and the causes. So, the causes we've talked about is the fixed mindset. And so, for teachers, it's really about challenging any fixed mindset that they see in the classroom. By the time kids get to high school, there are a lot of other external influences that are coming in. I think, just trying to challenge and discuss where students might have got a fixed mindset idea. There are really clever ways that you can ask your students to reflect on what types of ideas they have about maths.
One of the things we often talk about is maths metaphors. So you ask, you teach kids in high school how to write a metaphor and you ask them to write a metaphor on how they feel about maths and it can be a really great way to reveal a fixed mindset or any really negative idea. For instance, one year 11 student that did this activity said, ‘Maths is like being blindfolded and choosing a chocolate from a chocolate box when you have a nut allergy’.
One of the things that we also talk about that's really important is the symptoms. So, these are the things that you feel in the moment. These are the, we talk about physiological symptoms and cognitive symptoms. So physiological symptoms are exactly the same as any type of anxiety that you're feeling – so, the butterflies in your stomach, sweaty palms, racing heart. The cognitive symptoms are these really intrusive negative thoughts that you have like, ‘I'm never going to understand this’, ‘I'm going to be terrible at maths’, ‘I'm going to fail this test’, and things like that. These are really important to address.
And I think the other thing to acknowledge is that saying – and many teachers, and my mum that was a maths teacher used to say this to me as well – ‘Just don't worry about it. Math is fine, it's fine’. But if we think about it, if you're afraid of heights and you say to someone, ‘Just go out on the ledge, it's fine, you'll be fine’. That isn't going to help them calm down. So, the strategies that we look for there, we've got the strategies for physiological symptoms are really things like mindfulness, deep breathing, journaling, things like that. Things that a student can do. Some of those are things that a student can do in the classroom without anyone even noticing that they're doing it.
For the cognitive symptoms, it's about reframing some of those thoughts. It's also about expressive writing as well or journaling. We've got some great resources on the ACER website that really go into what these strategies might look like in the classroom (Buckley, et al., 2024). And there might be some of your listeners right now, particularly in secondary classrooms, who might be saying, ‘I'm sorry that mindfulness does not sit in a maths classroom’ because it's not really something that a lot of maths teachers think about. But we really are finding that teachers that are talking about these strategies with students, and suggesting them, are having some really powerful results. Having kids that are maybe fainting before a maths class or almost fainting to then having a go and persisting with it.
JE: That's great to hear, and as I mentioned, I'll put the links into all the resources that we're discussing today in the research in the transcript of this over at teachermagazine.com. Okay, let's turn our attention to the teachers then in terms of them feeling anxiety. What do we know from the research about that? Is that something that's increasing?
SB: I think it's something that is not necessarily increasing, but it's been something that has been an issue for a while.
JE: So, it's more visible now, isn't it? As we’re learning more about it.
SB: It’s more visible. It's something that we see more in primary teachers. That's, as I said before, there is some evidence that there are, it's where we see higher proportions of maths anxiety. At ACER we do a lot of work with pre-service teachers with this idea that if we can help teachers identify and address their own anxiety before they go out into the field, they can sort of take that with them.
But the strategies that we advocate for teachers are actually the same ones that we advocate for students. So those physiological, cognitive and those strategies to address the causes. But the importance is that if you're a teacher and you're maths anxious and you are learning these strategies, then you can also use them for your students. One of the other things that we find with pre-service teachers is, obviously not all pre-service teachers are anxious, but we see that the teachers that aren't anxious and that are really confident also benefit from learning about this. Because they will often say, ‘I've always been very confident at maths. I had no idea that people were anxious about it’. And they take that learning about strategies and understanding how anxiety operates and they take that into the classroom. And they're often a bit more empathetic when they're with students that are anxious because they understand more about the experience and how debilitating it can be.
JE: So, let's talk about some of the strategies then and I want to look at a few different cohorts. So, maybe we could talk about strategies for different ones if in fact the strategies are different. So, you've mentioned there about sort of the pre-service – so I’m thinking beginner teachers who are new to teaching, or relatively new to the profession. Those who are more experienced of course can still experience maths anxiety. And then the other group I was thinking about was those that are experienced and confident in their own subject area and now they've been asked to teach out of field, or maybe a casual relief teacher or something like that who's coming in, not used to teaching maths, and bang, you've got year 6 maths today. What are some of those strategies there that could help? I'm thinking in terms of things they can do themselves but also what colleagues, school leaders could be thinking about as well.
SB: So, I think, as I said, we've done a lot of work with pre-service teachers and pre-service teachers tend to be much more open about their anxiety if they are experiencing it. But teachers that are in the field are less likely because that's when that shame, I think, might be there.
So I think for maths leaders, it really is about starting a dialogue about maths anxiety and normalising it, not normalising it in terms of it's okay to feel it and just let it take over, but talking about how it is something that a lot of people experience, that it's something that can be addressed, reduced and regulated and that it can be sort of, your experience of anxiety can be improved by using some of those other strategies that I was talking about.
We did a research study, a pilot with 10 Victorian schools (Cook, 2018) and we had the numeracy leader come in for this as well as a cohort of teachers. And some of those teachers were anxious. And what we found is that by educating everyone about what maths anxiety is, and how it develops and what strategies can be used and the fact that the numeracy leader was on board and understanding and interested in understanding about teacher and student anxiety, that the teachers that were anxious suddenly were much more comfortable to go to their numeracy leader and say, ‘I'm actually experiencing anxiety and I have been worried about telling you about it because I was worried that my contract might not be renewed’. For instance, that was an extreme example.
But, so just starting to have some meetings where you talk about it, talk about the research, talk about some of the strategies, talk about how you might introduce some of these strategies like the mindfulness and the journaling, how you might challenge and change that fixed mindset because it is at the root cause of the anxiety experience. Talking about some of those things and mentioning that it might benefit teachers as well, that's going to open the conversation, open the door to the conversations around teacher anxiety. I think that's really important.
I think another thing to emphasise, in all of our work in maths anxiety we never talk about eliminating it, because anxiety is not a wholly bad thing. This is another sort of reframe about it that is really positive to tell to students and teachers. What we know is that if anxiety is really high, then it often impacts on working memory, it leads you long term to avoid maths. But if your anxiety is really low, that's not where your best performance is. Your best performance is where you've got a little bit of anxiety. So, a little bit of anxiety is great. That's okay. It can help us. We know that it's associated with value and caring about what we're doing.
What we want to do is we want to pull it down so that it's not operating at that high level. It's not stopping you from doing what you need to do. And I think it's really important that we kind of make sure that that's how we're talking about it and we're normalising it in that way. And we're also, I think, making sure that people think that anxiety is something that you can have control over, as opposed to it being like a life sentence. Because that is definitely the other thing I've heard people saying, ‘I'm math anxious, I'm just not a math person’, and therefore giving up.
JE: And it's never going to get better ... I really liked what you said about just even having that conversation. I mean, it starts with the conversation, doesn't it? And taking away that stigma and that feeling of sort of like, ‘I'm a teacher, I should know this stuff, I shouldn't be anxious about this stuff’. But also, I suppose it's really important from a perspective of, everybody's got different anxieties. It could be just one thing in particular. It could just be one topic that's coming up that the kind of they see later in the year and they're like, ‘Oh gosh, I really don't want to teach that’. But it builds and builds. So, it's just trying to understand what that personal experience as well is, isn't it?
SB: Yes, it is. And this approach is very psychology-based – which is, I think sometimes people when we talk about the fact that we're doing maths anxiety research and looking at how to address it often teachers are expecting a content knowledge approach to how to deal with it.
So, what we see most teachers do is if, so for instance if they have a student in their classroom who is really anxious then they go, ‘Okay, what I need to do is I need to build that student's confidence around maths and I need to build their liking of maths and therefore by doing that indirectly their anxiety will decrease’. And that does work for some students, but it doesn't work with the ones that are highly anxious. Because it's like that heights thing – if you're scared of heights and you say to the student, ‘Just jump off, it's fine. You've got a parachute, it's all good’ they're not really going to be on board. You've got to give them the strategy to reduce and regulate that anxiety that they're feeling in the moment. And then that work that you're doing to build their confidence, build their knowledge and their skills is going to be so much more effective.
JE: So, Sarah, I hear you'll be sharing maths anxiety resources at the upcoming Maths Association of Victoria conference in early December. Can you tell us a little bit about that?
SB: Sure. So, I have some wonderful ACER colleagues who will be at the MAV conference and they're going to have a maths anxiety toolkit resource pack for teachers to stop by and to pick up. And that is going to be a really fun maths anxiety showbag. There's going to be some resources in there. There's going to be some maths mindfulness colouring books, stress ball and other goodies. So, I would definitely encourage you, if you're a maths teacher and you're nearby, go pick up the showbag because it's going to be fun and it's also going to be useful for you.
JE: And luckily for anyone listening, we've grabbed some of the showbags. So, if you're not going to go to MAV, don't despair. I've got 5 showbags on my desk, and this giveaway is open to listeners in Australia where we're already planning for the new 2027 school year. Send an email to teachereditor@acer.org letting me know your teaching tips for how to get off to a strong start for Term 1 and I'll randomly draw 5 people to send the showbag to! So, some of those things that are in there, they've got a ‘what will you do next in maths?’ theme.
SB: Yeah, and we can look at that in a couple of different ways. Like literally, what are you doing next in maths? Are you studying fractions? Are you studying measurement? Or it can be about what do students need to do next in maths to tackle the anxiety that they're experiencing? For instance, should they challenge some of those thoughts that they're having in their head? Do they need to do some deep breathing? Do they need to do some mindfulness? Or it could be what are you going to do next in maths in terms of your future pathway? Like, what course or subject are you going to do next year because you want to be a psychologist, or you want to be an event planner, or you want to be a scientist. So that theme is really focusing on continuing to keep moving with maths.
JE: Brilliant. So, drop by the ACER booth at MAV and grab your showbag there, or email us for a chance to get your hands on one of those. Dr Sarah Buckley, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with The Research Files today. We're heading into the new year. Just before you go, what's your takeaway message then for teachers on maths anxiety in the classroom?
SB: I think it's that understanding that maths anxiety can present in a lot of different ways. It can be kids avoiding maths. It can be kids just being really disruptive, choosing to go to the toilet just before they know that maths is coming up. And so just to look out for it and please like read some of the resource information that Jo's going to post. Some of the resources have really good practical strategies and just give them a go and see if they work for you. We think they will.
That's all for this episode. Thanks for listening wherever you are. If you enjoyed this chat, please take a moment to follow our show on your podcast app if you haven't done that already and leave us a review because both of those things help more people like you to find our podcast and they're a really big support for the Teacher team. So, thank you for doing that. We'll be back with a new episode very soon.
Teacher magazine is published by the Australian Council for Educational Research.
References and related reading
Barroso, C., Ganley, C. M., McGraw, A. L., Geer, E. A., Hart, S. A., & Daucourt, M. C. (2021). A metaanalysis of the relation between math anxiety and math achievement. Psychological Bulletin, 147(2), 134–168. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000307
Buckley, S., Reid, K., Pearn, C. & Sniedze, S. (2024). ACER’s Mathematics Anxiety and Engagement Strategy (MAES): A framework. Australian Council for Educational Research. https://doi.org/10.37517/978-1-74286-736-6
Bursal, M., & Paznokas, L. (2006). Mathematics anxiety and preservice elementary teachers' confidence to teach mathematics and science. School science and mathematics, 106(4), 173-180. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1949-8594.2006.tb18073.x
Cook, H. (2018, August 21). 'I'm never going to understand this': the maths anxiety in our schools. The Age. https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/i-m-never-going-to-understand-this-the-maths-anxiety-in-our-schools-20180821-p4zyto.html
Ma, X. (1999). A meta-analysis of the relationship between anxiety toward mathematics and achievement in mathematics. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 30(5), 520-540. https://doi.org/10.2307/749772
Park, J., Ramirez, G., & Park, D. (2024). Effect of preschool teacher's math anxiety on teaching efficacy and classroom engagement in math. Psychology in the Schools, 61, 2600–2611. https://doi.org/10.1002/pits.23182
Pekrun, R. (2024). Control-Value Theory: From Achievement Emotion to a General Theory of Human Emotions. Educational Psychology Review, 36, 83 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-024-09909-7
Tomasetto, C., Morsanyi, K., Guardabassi, V., & O’Connor, P. A. (2021). Math anxiety interferes with learning novel mathematics contents in early elementary school. Journal of Educational Psychology, 113(2), 315–329. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000602
How comfortable do you and your colleagues feel discussing challenges or anxieties related to teaching mathematics and, as a school or subject leader, what could you do to create a culture where seeking support is seen as a strength rather than stigmatised?
What strategies does your school use to support students' emotional wellbeing during maths learning, and having listened to this episode and looked at the related reading and resources, what additional approaches could help reduce anxiety?
How confident are your students when it comes to making mistakes, asking questions and persisting when they find mathematics challenging? The podcast highlights the role of mindset and beliefs about maths. What messages about mathematical ability might students be receiving at school, at home or from wider society? With a group of colleagues, discuss how you could challenge these unhelpful assumptions.